2391 Old Rte 5 Sullivan, NY 13037
Property details
About 2391 Old Rte 5
Own a timepiece of early American charm with this stunning 5-bed, 2-bath Colonial on 8.34 acres in Madison County. Originally built in 1818, this home retains rich character—like exposed beams and original hardwoods and doors, along with 5 stone fireplaces. Spacious rooms, cozy radiators, and vintage details create a welcoming feel inside, while the land outside invites exploration. There is already chickens and a coop, and a barn for additional animals if desired. Whether you're looking for a homestead, a bed and breakfast or just love historic homes with space to breathe, this one's for you. Great location near Chittenango schools and just a quick drive to parks, shops, and Route 5 amenities.
Highlights
(Active Under Contract)
Virtual tour
Summary
- Full Bathrooms: 2
- Appliances: Dishwasher, Range, Gas Water Heater, Oven, Refrigerator, Water Softener
- Basement: Yes
- Flooring Type: Hardwood, Varies
- Interior: Entrance Foyer, Kitchen Island, Library, Living/Dining Room, Storage, Walk-In Pantry, Bedroom on Main Level, Workshop
- Total Bedroom Count: 5
- Garage Space: 1 space
- Attached Garage: No
- Parking: Detached, Garage, Driveway
- Exterior: Blacktop Driveway, Patio
- Architectural Style: Colonial, Historic/Antique
- Heating: Natural Gas, Hot Water, Radiant
- List Price: $375,000
- Price/SqFt: $115
- Lot: Irregular Lot
- Directions: NYS Route 5 to Old Route 5
- Year Built: 1818
- Stories: 2
- Living Area: 3,235 SqFt
- Lot Size: 8.34 Acres
- MLS Number: S1597678
- MLS Name: NYS
- Office Name: Chapin Real Estate
- Office Phone: (315) 366-4136
- Office Email: jen@jenniechapin.com
- Listing Agent: Kelly M. Erickson
The data relating to real estate on this website comes in part from the Internet Data Exchange (IDX) Program of NYSAMLS’s. Real estate listings held by other firms are marked with theListing Broker’s Firm Name. Data provided is for consumers’ personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties that consumers may be interested in purchasing. All information deemed reliable but not guaranteed and should be independently verified. All properties are subject to prior sale, change or withdrawal. Neither the listing broker(s) nor this firm shall be responsible for any typographical errors, misinformation, misprints, and shall be held totally
harmless.
© 2025 CNYIS, UNYREIS, WNYREIS. All rights reserved.
Data displayed may be a portion of, and not a complete set of all listings published in the MLS.
This advertisement does not suggest that the broker has a listing in this property or properties or that any property is currently available.
Last updated on: 6/3/2025, 7:45:28 PM Eastern. If you have any questions regarding the accuracy of this data, please contact us at help@rockethomes.com.
Get an agent. Get a mortgage. Save big.¹
$375,000
2391 Old Rte 5
$4,453
closing credit¹
Sell your home with Rocket and save even more!
Seller rebate
0.5% sale price²
Price information
Property sales
We're sorry, we currently don't have property sales data for this listing.
Tax history
We're sorry, we currently don't have tax history data for this listing.
Nearby schools
6
Bolivar Road Elementary School
Public District PK-4
2.7 mi
•6983 Bolivar Rd
5
South Side Elementary School
Public District 2-3
4.4 mi
•200 High St
10
Enders Road Elementary School
Public District KG-4
7.4 mi
•4725 Enders Rd
School ratings are a score out of 10, where 10 is the highest and 1 is the lowest.
Neighborhood
The neighbors living near this home have an average income of $67,817. Residents of Sullivan, NY typically earn between $35k-100k each year. The most common type of family is married, no kids. Typical level of education for residents in this area is post secondary degree.
How much money do the neighbors make?
What level of education do the neighbors have?
What types of families live nearby?
Are the neighbors home owners or renters?
How old are people in this area?
What do the neighbors do for fun?
Hunting
NASCAR
Figure Skating
Where do the neighbors shop?
Dick's Sporting Goods
Dillards
Wal-Mart
Where do the neighbors go to eat?
Texas Roadhouse
Cracker Barrel
Hardee's
What do the neighbors drive?
Subaru
Cadillac
Ram
What do the neighbors listen to?
New Country
News/Talk/Information
Classic Country
Frequently asked questions
About 2391 Old Rte 5
The listing price of 2391 Old Rte 5 property is $375,000.
The property 2391 Old Rte 5 is a house located in Sullivan, New York, 13037.
Accepting Backup Offers: 2391 Old Rte 5 is Accepting Backup Offers (Active Under Contract), there is still a chance to have your real estate agent submit an offer.
The nearby schools for 2391 Old Rte 5 are: Bolivar Road Elementary School (GreatSchools Rating 6/10), South Side Elementary School (GreatSchools Rating 5/10), Enders Road Elementary School (GreatSchools Rating 10/10), Chittenango Middle School (GreatSchools Rating 5/10), Roberts Street Middle School (GreatSchools Rating 6/10), Otto L Shortell Middle School (GreatSchools Rating 3/10), Chittenango High School (GreatSchools Rating 8/10), Canastota High School (GreatSchools Rating 4/10), Fayetteville-Manlius Senior High School (GreatSchools Rating 10/10).
The property at 2391 Old Rte 5 has 5 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms.
The property 2391 Old Rte 5 is 3,235 SqFt (source: MLS/tax record).
The year of construction for 2391 Old Rte 5 is 1818.
This home is located at 2391 Old Rte 5 in Sullivan, NY and zip code 13037. This 3,235 square foot home, which was built in 1818, sits on a 8.34 acre lot. Features: 5 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms. It has been listed on Rocket Homes since April 4, 2025 and is currently priced at $375,000.
Sullivan, NY housing market in May 2025 saw over 5 listings sold above listed price, more than 1 sold at listed price and over 0 sold below. The inventory of homes for sale in Sullivan, NY between April and May 2025 decreased by 2.3%. The median list price of listings available in May 2025 was $300,000, while the average time on the real estate market was 116 days.