#L3567654, Listing Office: Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty
$2,399,000 List price
5 Hagar Rd Shelter Island, NY 11964
$10,000
Closing credit¹
3 beds
2 full, 1 partial
3,312 sqft
$724 / sqft
House
Property details
About 5 Hagar Rd
Experience the epitome of coastal living in this meticulously maintained one-level home, nestled in a charming beach community. Renovated in 2012 by Fokine Construction, this stunning residence offers breathtaking water views of Menantic Creek from nearly every room. Inside, you'll find an open-concept floor plan featuring a vaulted living room with a cozy fireplace, a dining area, and a custom chef's kitchen. Step outside onto the waterside deck, adorned with mahogany railings and stainless wire, for a serene outdoor retreat. The primary bedroom is a true oasis, complete with two walk-in closets and a luxurious en-suite bathroom. Enjoy the tranquility of the 1.29-acre shared parcel extending into the creek. This quiet enclave offers the perfect blend of luxury and natural beauty, making it an ideal coastal retreat. Some of the exterior photos with white siding have been virtually altered.
Highlights
Home typeSingle Family Residence
HeatingENERGY STAR Qualified Equipment, Oil, Baseboard, Hot Water
StatusActive
CoolingCentral Air
Size3,312 sqft
Year built1962
ParkingAttached, Driveway, Garage Door Opener, Private
MLS #L3564455
Garage2 spaces
WaterfrontCreek, Waterfront, Water Access
ViewPanoramic, Water
Summary
- MLS Number: L3564455
- MLS Name: ONEKEY2
- Office Name: Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty
- Office Phone: (631) 749-1155
Listings courtesy of OneKey MLS as distributed by MLS GRID.
All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker or MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information. Properties displayed may be listed or sold by various participants in the MLS.
The data relating to real estate for sale on this web site comes in part from the Broker Reciprocity Program of the OneKey™ MLS. Real Estate listings held by brokerage firms other than this broker are marked with the Broker Reciprocity logo and detailed information about them includes the name of the listing brokers. This information is provided exclusively for consumers’ personal, non-commercial use, that it may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing.
The source of the displayed data is either the property owner or public record provided by non-governmental third parties. It is believed to be reliable but not guaranteed.
Information Copyright 2025, OneKey™ MLS. All Rights Reserved.
Data displayed may be a portion of, and not a complete set of all listings published in the MLS.
This advertisement does not suggest that the broker has a listing in this property or properties or that any property is currently available.
Last updated on: 4/4/2025, 4:11:51 PM Eastern. If you have any questions regarding the accuracy of this data, please contact us at help@rockethomes.com.
Get an agent. Get a mortgage. Save big.¹
$2,399,000
5 Hagar Rd
$10,000
closing credit¹
Sell your home with Rocket and save even more!
Seller rebate
0.5% sale price²
Price information
Property sales
We're sorry, we currently don't have property sales data for this listing.
Tax history
| Year | Assessment | Property Tax |
|---|---|---|
| 2023 | $949,000 | $- |
| 2022 | $949,000 | $5,973 |
| 2021 | $949,000 | $5,973 |
| 2020 | $940,000 | $5,831 |
| 2019 | $938,000 | $2,860 |
| 2018 | $935,000 | $- |
History based on county public records data.
Nearby schools
3
Greenport Elementary School
Public District PK-6
3.1 mi
•720 Front St
7
Southold Elementary School
Public District KG-6
4.3 mi
•420 Oaklawn Ave
5
Sag Harbor Elementary School
Public District PK-5
5.3 mi
•68 Hampton St
School ratings are a score out of 10, where 10 is the highest and 1 is the lowest.
Neighborhood
The neighbors living near this home have an average income of $74,627. The majority of Shelter Island, NY residents have income between $35k-100k annually. Most families are single, no kids. Most residents in this area have post secondary degree education.
How much money do the neighbors make?
15%
<35k
47%
35k-100k
27%
100k-200k
11%
200k+
What level of education do the neighbors have?
High School Diploma
Post Secondary Degree
Masters Degree
Doctorate
What types of families live nearby?
44%
Single, No Kids
9%
Single, with Kids
31%
Married, No Kids
16%
Married, with Kids
Are the neighbors home owners or renters?
Home Owners
Renters
How old are people in this area?
12%
<11 yrs old
7%
12-17 yrs old
12%
18-34 yrs old
46%
35-64 yrs old
23%
65+ yrs old
What do the neighbors do for fun?
Hunting
Figure Skating
NASCAR
Where do the neighbors shop?
Dillards
Dick's Sporting Goods
Dollar General
Where do the neighbors go to eat?
Cracker Barrel
Texas Roadhouse
Applebees
What do the neighbors drive?
Cadillac
Subaru
Ram
What do the neighbors listen to?
News/Talk/Information
New Country
Classic Country
All data provided by Home Junction and Claritas
Similar homes for sale
#L3578053, Listing Office: Douglas Elliman Real Estate
#L3592958, Listing Office: Douglas Elliman Real Estate
#L3590276, Listing Office: Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty
4 days on Rocket
#842673, Listing Office: Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty
Frequently asked questions
About 5 Hagar Rd
This home is located at 5 Hagar Rd in Shelter Island, NY and zip code 11964. This 3,312 square foot home was built in 1962. Features: 3 bedrooms, 3 bathrooms. It has been listed on Rocket Homes since July 9, 2024 and is currently priced at $2,399,000.
In March 2025, from all listings sold in Shelter Island, NY there were more than 1 sold above asking price, over 0 sold below and more than 0 were sold right at the asked price. In March 2025 in Shelter Island, NY there were equal homes for sale than in February. The median list price of listings available in March 2025 was $1,950,000, while the average time on the real estate market was 437 days.
From Rocket Homes Real Estate and based on county public records data.