Shelter Island Housing Market Report May 2025•Suffolk County, New York

hero building illustration for mobile

Housing Prices in Shelter Island, NY

How much do homes in Shelter Island, NY cost?

Housing Market Conditions

Is Shelter Island, NY a buyer’s or seller’s market?

Housing Market Conditions

This is the supply and demand for houses in an area based on home prices and trends.

Buyer’s Market

A buyer’s market occurs when the number of available properties for sale exceeds the number of buyers looking to purchase. In a buyer’s market, the supply exceeds the demand.

Neutral Market

A neutral market occurs when the number of buyers looking to purchase properties meets the number of available properties for sale. In a balanced market, there are enough homes to meet the demand.

Seller’s Market

A seller’s market occurs when there are more buyers looking to purchase properties than there are available homes on the market. In a seller’s market, the demand exceeds the supply.

Seller'sMarket

Buyer'sMarket

Shelter Island is a Seller's Market

Difference Since May 2024

At the same time last year, Shelter Island was a Buyer's Market.

Insight

Shelter Island is a Sellers Housing Market, which means prices tend to be higher and homes sell faster.

Median Sold Price

Median Sold Price
This is the middle price for which all homes in the area were sold. Half of all the homes sold were below this price, and half were above.
$1,900,000$898/SqFt
+$557,500
+41.5%

Based on all homes sold in the last 12 months

Insight

Homes in Shelter Island have sold for 41.5% more than they did a year ago.

Summary: The median home sold price in Shelter Island was $1,900,000 in May 2025, up 41.5% from last year, and the median price per square foot was $898.

Median Sold Price By Cities

Median Sold Price By Cities
This is the middle price for which all homes in the area were sold compared to surrounding cities. Half of all the homes sold were below this price, and half were above.
CityChange YoY
Shelter Island
+41.5%
Southold
-8.7%

Median Sold Price By Bedrooms

Median Sold Price By Bedrooms
This is the middle price for all homes actively listed in an area broken out by the number of bedrooms. Half of the homes are listed below this price, and half are above.
BedsMay 2024May 2025Change YoY
1--
N/A
2$902.5K$987.4K
+9.4%
3$1.2M$1.7M
+35.7%
4$1.7M$2.5M
+43.9%
5$1.6M$4.1M
+161.7%

Summary: Shelter Island housing price by bedroom type for May 2025, compared to the previous year. The home price for 1 bedroom homes did not change. The home price for 2 bedroom homes increased by +9.4%. The home price for 3 bedroom homes increased by +35.7%. The home price for 4 bedroom homes increased by +43.9%. The home price for 5 bedroom homes increased by +161.7%.

How does Shelter Island, NY compare with other places?

Market comparison tool

Data and numbers shown are subject to change and may vary based on different timeframes.

Shelter Island, NY

Housing supply in Shelter Island, NY

How many homes are available in Shelter Island, NY?

Number of Homes For Sale

Number of Homes For Sale
This is the total number of homes actively listed in an area.
Last Month2 months agoChange MoM
17Last MonthMay 2025
132 months agoApr 2025
+30.8 %
Change MoMApr – May

Summary: The Shelter Island real estate market had 17 homes for sale in May 2025, a 30.8 % increase compared to Apr 2025.

Number of Homes Sold

Number of Homes Sold
This is the total number of both homes sold and pending in an area.
Last Month2 months agoChange MoM
3Last MonthMay 2025
02 months agoApr 2025
+100.0 %
Change MoMApr – May

Homes For Sale By Bedroom Count

Homes For Sale By Bedroom Count
This is the total number of homes actively listed in an area by number of bedrooms.
BedsApr 2025May 2025Change MoM
100
0.0%
211
0.0%
335
+66.7%
445
+25.0%
556
+20.0%

Summary: Shelter Island housing inventory by bedroom type for May 2025, compared to the previous month. The inventory for 1 bedroom homes remained the same. The inventory for 2 bedroom homes remained the same. The inventory for 3 bedroom homes increased by +66.7%. The inventory for 4 bedroom homes increased by +25.0%. The inventory for 5 bedroom homes increased by +20.0%.

Asking Price vs. Sold Price

How much do homes in Shelter Island, NY cost?

Asking Price vs. Sold Price

The asking price is how much a home is listed for. The selling price is how much the home actually sold for.

Under Asking

Homes that sold for less than the asking price

At Asking

Homes that sold at their asking price

Over Asking

Homes that sold above the asking price

Over Asking Price0 Home

At Asking Price1 Home

Under Asking Price2 Homes

Insight

If you're buying a home in Shelter Island, you may be able to get a good deal. 66.7% of homes here sold below asking price last month.

Summary: A total of 3 homes were sold or pending in Shelter Island in May 2025, up by 100.0% month-over-month. Of the 3 sold homes, 67% were sold under asking, 33% were sold at asking, and and 0% were sold over asking.

Days on Market for Shelter Island, NY

How long does it take to sell a home in Shelter Island, NY?

Breakdown of Home Sale Times

Under 30 Days2 Homes

30 – 90 Days0 Home

Over 90 Days1 Home

Insight

Many homes in Shelter Island are selling fast, if you're buying plan to act quickly.

Summary: During May 2025, 3 homes were sold in Shelter Island; 67% of homes were sold within 30 days, 0% of homes were sold within 30 to 90 days, and 33% of homes were sold over 90 days.

Average Sale Time

Average Sale Time
This is the average number of days homes take to sell in an area.
This Year1 year agoChange YoY
70 DaysThis YearMay 2025
108 Days1 year agoMay 2024
-35.2 %
Change YoYMay 2024 – May 2025

Summary: Homes in Shelter Island had an average listing age of 70 days in May 2025, down by 35.2% compared to the previous year.

Connect With An Agent

Local real estate agents are ready to help you find a home here

Sell My Home

Sell your home with an expert or get the job done on your own.

Get Approved

Get a customizable mortgage solution based on today's rates.

Newest Listings in Shelter Island, NY

What homes are available in Shelter Island, NY?

See More Listings

Nearby markets

Popular Cities with Homes for Sale in New York

MLS Disclaimers and Copyright

Based on information from OneKey MLS, for the period 06/01/2023 - 06/01/2025

IDX Listings courtesy of OneKey MLS as distributed by MLS GRID.

All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker or MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information. Properties displayed may be listed or sold by various participants in the MLS.

DMCA Notice

IDXThe data relating to real estate for sale on this web site comes in part from the Broker Reciprocity Program of the OneKey™ MLS. Real Estate listings held by brokerage firms other than this broker are marked with the Broker Reciprocity logo and detailed information about them includes the name of the listing brokers. This information is provided exclusively for consumers’ personal, non-commercial use, that it may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing.

The source of the displayed data is either the property owner or public record provided by non-governmental third parties. It is believed to be reliable but not guaranteed.

Information Copyright 2025, OneKey™ MLS. All Rights Reserved.
Data displayed may be a portion of, and not a complete set of all listings published in the MLS.

This advertisement does not suggest that the broker has a listing in this property or properties or that any property is currently available.
Last updated on: 6/24/2025, 11:41:29 AM Eastern. If you have any questions regarding the accuracy of this data, please contact us at help@rockethomes.com.