Single family homes for sale in Monticello, NY

2 hours on Rocket

$5,629 Closing Credit¹

$474,000

6 beds • 2.5 baths • 2,745 sqft

37 Starr Ave, Monticello, NY 12701

#867383, Listing Office: Nationwide Houses LLC

2 days on Rocket

$5,926 Closing Credit¹

$499,000

3 beds • 2 baths • 1,575 sqft

674 Sackett Lake Rd, Monticello, NY 12701

#864850, Listing Office: Barbanti Group

Save big

You could save thousands when you partner with Rocket Homes℠ and Rocket Mortgage®

Coming soon

$5,344 Closing Credit¹

$449,999

3 beds • 2.5 baths • 2,472 sqft

323 Harris Rd, Monticello, NY 12701

#866588, Listing Office: Keller Williams Realty

4 days on Rocket

$6,413 Closing Credit¹

$540,000

4 beds • 2.5 baths • 1,940 sqft

26 Stacey Dr, Monticello, NY 12701

#866169, Listing Office: NexLvl Real Estate Inc.

6 days on Rocket

$4,631 Closing Credit¹

$390,000

4 beds • 2.5 baths • 1,720 sqft

29 Nelshore Dr, Monticello, NY 12701

#862953, Listing Office: eRealty Advisors, Inc

7 days on Rocket

$10,000 Closing Credit¹

$1,350,000

5 beds • 6 baths • 6,426 sqft

935 Starlight Rd, Monticello, NY 12701

#864873, Listing Office: Rhulen Realty Group LLC

7 days on Rocket

$2,968 Closing Credit¹

$249,900

5 beds • 2 baths • 2,300 sqft

47 Waverly Ave, Monticello, NY 12701

#864168, Listing Office: Point Realty USA

Room to negotiate?

Median Sold Price

$297K

Avg. Sale Time

185 Days

Based on our April 2025 Market Report.

$10,000 Closing Credit¹

$849,900

4 beds • 4 baths • 4,536 sqft

16 Kukas Rd, Monticello, NY 12701

#862564, Listing Office: The Maxx Group LLC

$5,818 Closing Credit¹

$489,900

3 beds • 3 baths • 1,918 sqft

3342 State Route 42, Monticello, NY 12701

#862425, Listing Office: Keller Williams Hudson Valley

$4,513 Closing Credit¹

$380,000

4 beds • 2 baths • 2,400 sqft

36 Starr Ave, Monticello, NY 12701

#862062, Listing Office: Master Realty Group Inc.

$4,155 Closing Credit¹

$349,900

3 beds • 1.5 baths • 1,704 sqft

198 Dillon Rd, Monticello, NY 12701

#861733, Listing Office: Rieber Realty Inc

$4,037 Closing Credit¹

$339,999

3 beds • 1.5 baths • 1,564 sqft

21 Hammond St, Monticello, NY 12701

#861310, Listing Office: Rodeo Realty Inc

$6,828 Closing Credit¹

$575,000

6 beds • 2 baths • 4,300 sqft

541 Broadway, Monticello, NY 12701

#859468, Listing Office: Team W Realty LLC

$5,000,000

14 beds • 14.5 baths • 17,570 sqft

399 Gregory Rd, Monticello, NY 12701

#858111, Listing Office: Master Realty Group Inc.

$4,156 Closing Credit¹

$350,000

3 beds • 3 baths • 1,112 sqft

20 Lakeview Ter, Monticello, NY 12701

#H6326001, Listing Office: Coldwell Banker Village Green

$3,858 Closing Credit¹

$324,900

3 beds • 2 baths • 1,420 sqft

67 Old Ryan Rd, Monticello, NY 12701

#857159, Listing Office: Greene Realty Group

$8,301 Closing Credit¹

$699,000

9 beds • 6.5 baths • 4,368 sqft

93 Wood Ave, Monticello, NY 12701

#856522, Listing Office: Catskills Home Services

$6,353 Closing Credit¹

$535,000

4 beds • 3 baths • 2,288 sqft

252 Southwoods Dr, Monticello, NY 12701

#854307, Listing Office: BHG Real Estate Green Team

$4,144 Closing Credit¹

$349,000

4 beds • 1.5 baths • 2,198 sqft

15 N St, Monticello, NY 12701

#854100, Listing Office: Catskills Home Services

$2,909 Closing Credit¹

$244,999

2 beds • 1 bath • 750 sqft

89 Cold Spring Rd, Monticello, NY 12701

#837895, Listing Office: Rodeo Realty Inc

$10,000 Closing Credit¹

$1,895,000

5 beds • 3.5 baths • 2,400 sqft

836 Starlight Rd, Monticello, NY 12701

#850860, Listing Office: Resort Realty

$4,750 Closing Credit¹

$399,999

5 beds • 3 baths • 1,754 sqft

4 Ann St, Monticello, NY 12701

#841463, Listing Office: Rodeo Realty Inc

$4,738 Closing Credit¹

$399,000

4 beds • 3.5 baths • 2,352 sqft

487 Southwoods Dr, Monticello, NY 12701

#852611, Listing Office: Rieber Realty Inc

$7,113 Closing Credit¹

$599,000

5 beds • 3.5 baths • 2,584 sqft

44 Floral Dr, Monticello, NY 12701

#842338, Listing Office: Team W Realty LLC

$6,519 Closing Credit¹

$549,000

3 beds • 3 baths • 1,754 sqft

14 Dollard Dr, Monticello, NY 12701

#833594, Listing Office: Team W Realty LLC

$10,000 Closing Credit¹

$899,000

6 beds • 4 baths • 2,432 sqft

181 Starlight Rd, Monticello, NY 12701

#801821, Listing Office: Rhulen Realty Group LLC

$4,738 Closing Credit¹

$399,000

3 beds • 2.5 baths • 1,772 sqft

10 Hanover Dr, Monticello, NY 12701

#841692, Listing Office: Keller Williams Hudson Valley

$4,619 Closing Credit¹

$389,000

4 beds • 2 baths • 53,579 sqft

59 Clinton Ave, Monticello, NY 12701

#849765, Listing Office: Aida Home Realty

$2,363 Closing Credit¹

$199,000

2 beds • 1 bath • 748 sqft

700 Sackett Lake Rd, Monticello, NY 12701

#849555, Listing Office: Century 21 Alliance Rlty Group

$5,878 Closing Credit¹

$495,000

3 beds • 2 baths • 3,100 sqft

78 Cold Spring Rd, Monticello, NY 12701

#843213, Listing Office: Resort Realty

$5,332 Closing Credit¹

$449,000

3 beds • 1 bath • 1,192 sqft

37 Nelshore Dr, Monticello, NY 12701

#843295, Listing Office: Team W Realty LLC

$4,394 Closing Credit¹

$370,000

3 beds • 1 bath • 1,613 sqft

9 Washington St, Monticello, NY 12701

#837856, Listing Office: Pennywise Properties

$5,094 Closing Credit¹

$429,000

4 beds • 2 baths • 2,040 sqft

16 Fairchild Pl, Monticello, NY 12701

#834496, Listing Office: Team W Realty LLC

$6,519 Closing Credit¹

$549,000

3 beds • 1.5 baths • 1,560 sqft

38 Marjorie Dr, Monticello, NY 12701

#833366, Listing Office: RE/MAX Distinguished Hms.&Prop

$4,038 Closing Credit¹

$340,000

2 beds • 2 baths • 1,416 sqft

21 Rock Ridge Ave, Monticello, NY 12701

#829356, Listing Office: Pennywise Properties

$9,197 Closing Credit¹

$774,500

4 beds • 3.5 baths • 3,490 sqft

108 Browns Rd, Montgomery, NY 12549

#829069, Listing Office: RE/MAX Benchmark Realty Group

$2,363 Closing Credit¹

$199,000

1 bed • 1 bath • 408 sqft

22 Smith St, Monticello, NY 12701

#818114, Listing Office: Resort Realty

$3,622 Closing Credit¹

$305,000

3 beds • 2 baths • 1,792 sqft

290 Hilltop Rd, Monticello, Ny, NY 12701

#PW250128, Emma G Djiya, Listing Office: 1ST CLASS REALTY - PA

$6,994 Closing Credit¹

$589,000

4 beds • 2.5 baths • 3,376 sqft

19 Forest Ln, Monticello, NY 12701

#812118, Listing Office: Century 21 Country Realty

$3,622 Closing Credit¹

$305,000

3 beds • 2 baths • 1,792 sqft

290 Hilltop Rd, Monticello, NY 12701

#812350, Listing Office: 1st Class Realty

Monticello, NY Real Estate Market Overview

There are 51 single family homes for sale in Monticello, NY. The following market insights reflect all property types in the Monticello, NY real estate market. The inventory of homes for sale in Monticello, NY between March 2025 and April 2025 increased by 32.1%. While the average time on the market in April 2025 was 185 days, the median list price was $297,030. Monticello, NY housing market in April 2025 saw over 0 listings sold above listed price, more than 1 sold at listed price and over 2 sold below.

From Rocket Homes Real Estate and based on county public records data

What is it like to live in Monticello, NY

Overview

Monticello is located in Sullivan County, New York. There are roughly 4,639 residents, living in 1,860 households. The average temperature for Monticello this time of the year is low of 44F and high of 67F. On average, Monticello gets about 4.87 inches of precipitation in May. 31% residents are home owners, have a high school diploma (58%) and are single, no kids (54%).

Data provided by Home Junction

Single family homes for sale in Monticello, NY

Monticello, NY Real Estate Market Overview

What is it like to live in Monticello, NY

Overview

Explore popular home types in Monticello, NY

Related homes in Monticello, NY

Schools near Monticello, NY

Housing market reports in Sullivan County

Homes for sale near Monticello, NY

Top real estate cities in New York