5 bedroom homes for sale in Oyster Bay, NY

view of front of home with a front yard, fence, solar panels, and concrete driveway

kitchen with stainless steel appliances, dark countertops, a sink, and white cabinetry

laundry room with laundry area, baseboards, visible vents, stacked washer / dryer, and dark wood-style flooring

New - 1 day on Rocket

$10,000 Closing Credit¹

$1,698,888

5 beds • 4 baths • 2,787 sqft

1 Pleasant Ave, Brooklyn NY 11803

#489425, Listing Office: Lombardo Homes & Estates

view of front of house with a front yard, stone siding, fence, and a chimney

view of front facade with a front lawn, a chimney, a shingled roof, and fence

living area with light wood finished floors, radiator heating unit, crown molding, a healthy amount of sunlight, and a fireplace

Coming soon3D tour

$10,000 Closing Credit¹

$1,095,000

5 beds • 2 baths

9 Hillside Ave, Woodbury NY 11797

#826534, Listing Office: Redfin Real Estate

Save big

You could save thousands when you partner with Rocket Homes℠ and Rocket Mortgage®

victorian-style house featuring a front yard, roof with shingles, and fence

New - 3 days on Rocket

$10,000 Closing Credit¹

$934,000

5 beds • 2 baths • 2,100 sqft

4041 Jean Ave, Bethpage NY 11714

#825931, Listing Office: HomeSmart Premier Living Rlty

view of front of house with a front lawn and a garage

New - 4 days on Rocket

$9,262 Closing Credit¹

$779,999

5 beds • 2 baths • 2,200 sqft

39 Alpine Ln, Hicksville NY 11801

#825320, Listing Office: Signature Premier Properties

view of front of property with a front lawn

New - 5 days on Rocket

$9,488 Closing Credit¹

$799,000

5 beds • 3 baths • 2,600 sqft

20 Hemlock Dr, Farmingdale NY 11735

#825301, Listing Office: Greene Realty Group

view of front of home with a garage and a front lawn

view of front facade with a garage and a front lawn

view of front of house with a garage and a front lawn

$10,000 Closing Credit¹

$998,000

5 beds • 3 baths • 1,810 sqft

5 Thimble Ln, Hicksville NY 11801

#824215, Listing Office: Barillas Realty Inc

craftsman-style home with a garage and a front lawn

view of front facade featuring a garage and a front lawn

entrance foyer with coffered ceiling, beam ceiling, and light hardwood / wood-style flooring

$10,000 Closing Credit¹

$1,749,999

5 beds • 3 baths • 3,250 sqft

10 Preston Ln, Syosset NY 11791

#824383, Listing Office: Douglas Elliman Real Estate

Room to negotiate?

Median Sold Price

$831.7K

Avg. Sale Time

76 Days

Based on our January 2025 Market Report.

front of property with a garage, central AC unit, and a front yard

property view of water featuring a beach view

$10,000 Closing Credit¹

$2,400,000

5 beds • 3.5 baths • 4,598 sqft

43 Oak Point Dr N, Bayville NY 11709

#822776, Listing Office: Real Broker NY LLC

single story home featuring a garage and a front lawn

$10,000 Closing Credit¹

$1,499,000

5 beds • 3.5 baths • 3,414 sqft

160 Harbor Ln, Massapequa Park NY 11762

#824301, Listing Office: EXIT Realty Premier

back house at dusk featuring a yard and a garage

kitchen with appliances with stainless steel finishes, light stone countertops, sink, and backsplash

$10,000 Closing Credit¹

$1,149,999

5 beds • 4 baths • 3,300 sqft

11 Gardenia Ln, Hicksville NY 11801

#822773, Listing Office: Realty Connect USA LLC

interior space featuring french doors, a multi sided fireplace, a chandelier, and light hardwood / wood-style flooring

$10,000 Closing Credit¹

$2,288,000

5 beds • 4.5 baths • 4,800 sqft

42 Waterview Ave, Massapequa NY 11758

#823656, Listing Office: AAA Young Shuen Realty Inc

bonus room with wood-type flooring and lofted ceiling

$7,719 Closing Credit¹

$649,990

5 beds • 4 baths • 1,524 sqft

165 Cherry St, Farmingdale NY 11735

#823042, Listing Office: Coldwell Banker American Homes

view of front facade with french doors and a garage

view of front of property featuring a garage

$10,000 Closing Credit¹

$2,180,000

5 beds • 5.5 baths • 5,982 sqft

121 Laurel Ln, Syosset NY 11791

#822538, Listing Office: Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty

playroom featuring a fireplace and wood-type flooring

$10,000 Closing Credit¹

$1,900,000

5 beds • 4.5 baths • 3,892 sqft

959 Ripley Ln, Upper Brookville NY 11771

#822709, Listing Office: Realty Masters North Shore

modern farmhouse with a garage and a front yard

view of front of property with a garage and a front yard

$10,000 Closing Credit¹

$1,399,990

5 beds • 4 baths • 3,150 sqft

76 Dorothy St, Bethpage NY 11714

#822528, Listing Office: No Nonsense Real Estate Inc

modern farmhouse featuring a garage and a front lawn

view of front of house with a garage and a front yard

back of property featuring a lawn and central air condition unit

$10,000 Closing Credit¹

$1,399,990

5 beds • 4 baths • 3,150 sqft

78 Dorothy St, Bethpage NY 11714

#822525, Listing Office: No Nonsense Real Estate Inc

kitchen with sink, black appliances, white cabinets, and light stone countertops

kitchen with stainless steel appliances, white cabinetry, hanging light fixtures, and blue cabinetry

$10,000 Closing Credit¹

$1,198,000

5 beds • 3 baths • 2,150 sqft

18 Park Dr E, Syosset NY 11791

#822369, Listing Office: Sweet Key Realty Group Inc

view of front facade with a garage and a front yard

$3,398,000

5 beds • 6 baths • 6,680 sqft

6 Danton Ln, Lattingtown NY 11560

#817691, Listing Office: Douglas Elliman Real Estate

view of front of property with a porch and a front lawn

view of side of property featuring a lawn

$10,000 Closing Credit¹

$1,950,000

5 beds • 4.5 baths • 3,850 sqft

68 Glenlawn Ave, Sea Cliff NY 11579

#820430, Listing Office: Compass Greater NY LLC

back of house featuring a yard and french doors

view of front of house featuring a garage and a front yard

$10,000 Closing Credit¹

$1,100,000

5 beds • 4.5 baths • 4,160 sqft

155 Royston Ln, Oyster Bay Cove NY 11771

#820716, Listing Office: REALHome Services & Solutions

view of front of home featuring a wall mounted air conditioner and a porch

corridor featuring crown molding, dark hardwood / wood-style flooring, and a baseboard radiator

$10,000 Closing Credit¹

$1,700,000

5 beds • 2.5 baths • 3,168 sqft

2 Old Cedar Swamp Rd, Jericho NY 11753

#820602, Listing Office: Next Phase Realty LLC

$10,000 Closing Credit¹

$1,982,000

5 beds • 4.5 baths • 5,246 sqft

1 Meadowlark Ln, Oyster Bay Cove NY 11771

#819984, Listing Office: Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty

view of front of house with a front lawn

living room featuring wood-type flooring, brick wall, and a textured ceiling

living room with light hardwood / wood-style floors, a textured ceiling, and baseboard heating

$8,728 Closing Credit¹

$735,000

5 beds • 2 baths • 2,129 sqft

267 Violet St, Massapequa Park NY 11762

#816658, Listing Office: Redfin Real Estate

$2,690,000

5 beds • 4 baths • 6,300 sqft

199 Terrace Ln, Upper Brookville NY 11771

#819570, Listing Office: Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty

$10,000 Closing Credit¹

$875,000

5 beds • 3 baths • 2,456 sqft

8 Deans Ln, Bayville NY 11709

#819419, Listing Office: Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty

stairway with a towering ceiling and a decorative wall

spare room featuring beam ceiling, coffered ceiling, a wainscoted wall, and wood finished floors

$4,295,000

5 beds • 4.5 baths • 3,000 sqft

145A Cedar Swamp Rd, Jericho NY 11753

#819247, Listing Office: Signature Premier Properties

tudor home featuring a garage and a front yard

$8,301 Closing Credit¹

$699,000

5 beds • 2.5 baths • 2,800 sqft

15 Bayview St E, Massapequa NY 11758

#818863, Listing Office: Blackstone Realty

hallway with hardwood / wood-style floors and a towering ceiling

living room featuring hardwood / wood-style flooring and a high ceiling

$10,000 Closing Credit¹

$1,499,998

5 beds • 3.5 baths • 3,511 sqft

17 Princeton Dr, Syosset NY 11791

#818154, Listing Office: Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty

$10,000 Closing Credit¹

$1,898,000

5 beds • 4.5 baths • 3,550 sqft

43 Burtis Ln, Syosset NY 11791

#817729, Listing Office: Douglas Elliman Real Estate

modern inspired farmhouse featuring a garage and a front yard

modern farmhouse style home with a garage and a front lawn

$10,000 Closing Credit¹

$1,926,000

5 beds • 4.5 baths • 3,800 sqft

15 Maggio Ln, Old Bethpage NY 11804

#818534, Listing Office: Douglas Elliman Real Estate

$3,140,000

5 beds • 3.5 baths • 3,457 sqft

15 Morgan Dr, Old Westbury NY 11568

#817874, Listing Office: Topaz NY Marketing Corp

view of front facade with a garage, covered porch, and a front lawn

new england style home featuring a front lawn and a storage unit

$10,000 Closing Credit¹

$2,249,000

5 beds • 4.5 baths • 4,036 sqft

7 Wellington Rd, Locust Valley NY 11560

#817137, Listing Office: Compass Greater NY LLC

view of front facade with a garage, a front lawn, and an outdoor structure

view of front of home with central AC and a front lawn

$10,000 Closing Credit¹

$1,299,999

5 beds • 3 baths • 3,150 sqft

183 Park Ln, Massapequa NY 11758

#816830, Listing Office: SRG Residential LLC

view of front of home featuring covered porch

$10,000 Closing Credit¹

$1,600,000

5 beds • 3.5 baths • 3,795 sqft

229A Glengariff, Massapequa Park NY 11762

#815199, Listing Office: Serhant LLC

unfurnished room featuring dark wood-type flooring

$10,000 Closing Credit¹

$1,480,000

5 beds • 3 baths • 2,200 sqft

66 Rockland Dr, Jericho NY 11753

#816307, Listing Office: Skylux Realty Inc

carpeted living room with a large fireplace and lofted ceiling

$10,000 Closing Credit¹

$2,499,000

5 beds • 3 baths • 3,810 sqft

10 Rolling Hill Rd, Old Westbury NY 11568

#815750, Listing Office: Compass Greater NY LLC

craftsman inspired home with a garage and a front yard

$10,000 Closing Credit¹

$1,698,888

5 beds • 3 baths • 3,200 sqft

46 Colonial Rd, Old Bethpage NY 11804

#815738, Listing Office: Douglas Elliman Real Estate

view of front of house with a garage, a front lawn, and french doors

view of front of home with french doors, a garage, and a front lawn

entrance foyer with light wood-type flooring

$10,000 Closing Credit¹

$1,549,000

5 beds • 4 baths • 3,500 sqft

200 Bayview Ave, Massapequa NY 11758

#815440, Listing Office: EXP Realty

colonial house featuring a front yard and a garage

view of front facade featuring a garage and a front yard

$3,000,000

5 beds • 7 baths • 7,900 sqft

5 Woodward Dr, Oyster Bay Cove NY 11771

#816043, Listing Office: Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty

view of front of house with a front yard

kitchen featuring white appliances, white cabinets, decorative backsplash, sink, and light tile patterned floors

living room featuring wood-type flooring and a baseboard heating unit

$9,369 Closing Credit¹

$789,000

5 beds • 2 baths • 2,272 sqft

6 Lantern Rd, Hicksville NY 11801

#816005, Listing Office: Signature Premier Properties

Oyster Bay, NY Real Estate Market Overview

Find your perfect 5 bedroom home in Oyster Bay, NY. Browse 5 in Oyster Bay, NY and connect with a Rocket Homes agent to get your dream home. The inventory of homes for sale in Oyster Bay, NY between December 2024 and January 2025 decreased by 13.6%. The median list price of listings available in January 2025 was $831,799, while the average time on the real estate market was 76 days. In January 2025 more than 63 listings in Oyster Bay, NY were sold above the asking price. During the same period more than 12 listings were sold at asking price, while more than 88 were sold below.

From Rocket Homes Real Estate and based on county public records data

Schools near Oyster Bay, NY

Elementary Schools

Pasadena Elementary School
3 Richard Ct
Public District KG-4
Boardman Elementary School #9E
170 Beatrice Ave
Public District 1-6
Searingtown School
106 Beverly Dr
Public District KG-5

Middle Schools

Wisdom Lane Middle School
120 Center Ln
Public District 6-8
Southside Middle School
67 Hillside Ave
Public District 6-8
H B Thompson Middle School
98 Ann Dr
Public District 6-8

High Schools

North Shore Senior High School
450 Glen Cove Ave
Public District 9-12
Seaford Senior High School
1575 Seamans Neck Rd
Public District 9-12
Oceanside High School #7
3160 Skillman Ave
Public District 9-12

Data provided by Great Schools

5 bedroom homes for sale in Oyster Bay, NY

Oyster Bay, NY Real Estate Market Overview

What is it like to live in Oyster Bay, NY

Overview

Explore popular home types in Oyster Bay, NY

Related homes in Oyster Bay, NY

Schools near Oyster Bay, NY

Housing market reports in Nassau County

Homes for sale near Oyster Bay, NY

Real estate in Oyster Bay neighborhoods

Top real estate cities in New York