Fire Island, NY homes for sale & real estate

birds eye view of property with a water view

New - 7 days on Rocket

$3,200,000

9 beds • 9.5 baths • 500 sqft

22 Atlantic Walk, Fire Island Pines NY 11782

#818745, Listing Office: Muroff Hospitality Group

living room with wooden ceiling, a wood stove, light hardwood / wood-style flooring, and vaulted ceiling with beams

kitchen featuring stainless steel range with electric stovetop, wooden ceiling, white cabinetry, and wooden walls

Video tour

$10,000 Closing Credit¹

$1,850,000

5 beds • 2 baths • 2,470 sqft

100 Clipper Roadway, Ocean Beach NY 11770

#812247, Listing Office: Netter Real Estate Inc

Save big

You could save thousands when you partner with Rocket Homes℠ and Rocket Mortgage®

living room featuring a healthy amount of sunlight, a wall unit AC, and hardwood / wood-style floors

living area with vaulted ceiling and dark wood-type flooring

$10,000 Closing Credit¹

$895,000

2 beds • 1 bath • 700 sqft

35 Bayview Walk, Cherry Grove NY 11782

#814777, Listing Office: Summer Place Realty

dining space featuring tile patterned flooring, beamed ceiling, and wood walls

$10,000 Closing Credit¹

$1,695,000

3 beds • 2 baths • 1,200 sqft

470 Ocean, Fire Island Pines NY 11782

#811211, Listing Office: Vinnie Petrarca Fire Island

rear view of property featuring a fenced in pool

kitchen with white cabinetry, sink, stainless steel appliances, backsplash, and light hardwood / wood-style floors

$10,000 Closing Credit¹

$1,125,000

2 beds • 2 baths • 860 sqft

521 Fire Island Blvd, Fire Island Pines NY 11782

#810697, Listing Office: Vinnie Petrarca Fire Island

living room featuring beamed ceiling, wooden ceiling, and wooden walls

dining room with light hardwood / wood-style flooring, beamed ceiling, and wooden ceiling

$10,000 Closing Credit¹

$1,999,000

4 beds • 3 baths • 2,750 sqft

617 Shore Walk, Fire Island Pines NY 11782

#804398, Listing Office: Vinnie Petrarca Fire Island

$2,850,000

6 beds • 6.5 baths • 3,000 sqft

362 Ocean Walk, Fire Island Pines NY 11782

#804210, Listing Office: Vinnie Petrarca Fire Island

Room to negotiate?

Median Sold Price

$995K

Avg. Sale Time

173 Days

Based on our January 2025 Market Report.

bar featuring beamed ceiling, dark hardwood / wood-style floors, sink, and stainless steel appliances

kitchen featuring sink, stainless steel appliances, light hardwood / wood-style floors, a kitchen bar, and wooden walls

$10,000 Closing Credit¹

$1,600,000

5 beds • 2 baths • 1,152 sqft

1 Seajay Walk, Davis Park NY 11772

#L3591567, Listing Office: Belzak & Bodkin Realty Corp

living room with ceiling fan, wood walls, wooden ceiling, and vaulted ceiling

$10,000 Closing Credit¹

$1,275,000

4 beds • 2 baths

146 Doctors Walk, Cherry Grove NY 11782

#L3590426, Listing Office: Summer Place Realty

kitchen with white cabinetry, beverage cooler, dark hardwood / wood-style floors, island exhaust hood, and a kitchen bar

living room featuring light hardwood / wood-style flooring and ceiling fan

$10,000 Closing Credit¹

$1,995,000

5 beds • 4 baths • 2,000 sqft

337 Shell Walk, Fire Island Pines NY 11782

#L3588268, Listing Office: Vinnie Petrarca Fire Island

living room featuring beam ceiling, wood-type flooring, wooden walls, and wooden ceiling

dining area featuring beam ceiling, hardwood / wood-style flooring, high vaulted ceiling, and wooden ceiling

$10,000 Closing Credit¹

$1,625,000

4 beds • 1.5 baths • 1,500 sqft

94 Pine Rd, Fair Harbor NY 11706

#L3588211, Listing Office: Nicholas Jay Newman

drone / aerial view with a water view and a beach view

$2,750,000

4 beds • 2 baths

39 Sloop Walk, Ocean Beach NY 11770

#L3585302, Listing Office: Netter Real Estate Inc

$10,000 Closing Credit¹

$999,999

3 beds • 2 baths

47 Lone Hill Walk, Fire Island Pines NY 11782

#L3585063, Listing Office: Vinnie Petrarca Fire Island

view of swimming pool featuring a deck and an in ground hot tub

view of swimming pool featuring a deck with water view

$2,700,000

3 beds • 2 baths • 1,208 sqft

146 Ocean Walk, Fire Island Pines NY 11782

#L3584525, Listing Office: BEKIN

misc room featuring vaulted ceiling with beams, a healthy amount of sunlight, wood ceiling, and ceiling fan

$10,000 Closing Credit¹

$1,500,000

2 beds • 1 bath • 684 sqft

17 Superior St, Ocean Bay Park NY 11770

#L3583408, Listing Office: Your Home Sold Guaranteed Rlty

view of pool with an outdoor living space and a wooden deck

view of pool featuring an outdoor hangout area and a deck

$10,000 Closing Credit¹

$1,275,000

2 beds • 2 baths

31 Lone Hill Walk, Fire Island Pines NY 11782

#L3578612, Listing Office: Vinnie Petrarca Fire Island

rear view of house featuring a balcony and a fenced in pool

$10,000 Closing Credit¹

$1,995,000

5 beds • 4.5 baths

287 Bay Walk, Fire Island Pines NY 11782

#L3578105, Listing Office: Vinnie Petrarca Fire Island

interior space with a beach view, a water view, and an AC wall unit

wooden terrace featuring a water view and a view of the beach

kitchen featuring stainless steel dishwasher, black gas stovetop, a wall mounted AC, a water view, and a stone fireplace

$10,000 Closing Credit¹

$1,995,000

4 beds • 3 baths

1 Ocean Walk, Fire Island Pines NY 11782

#L3576695, Listing Office: Vinnie Petrarca Fire Island

living room featuring lofted ceiling, a water view, and light wood-type flooring

wooden terrace with a water view and a view of the beach

kitchen featuring light hardwood / wood-style floors, sink, an AC wall unit, white fridge, and white cabinetry

$10,000 Closing Credit¹

$999,000

2 beds • 1 bath

C-04 Ocean Walk Unit 4, Fire Island Pines NY 11782

#L3576283, Listing Office: Vinnie Petrarca Fire Island

dining space featuring hardwood / wood-style flooring, wood walls, and lofted ceiling

living room featuring a wealth of natural light, wood walls, and vaulted ceiling

$6,531 Closing Credit¹

$550,000

2 beds • 1 bath

12 Ivy Walk, Cherry Grove NY 11782

#L3562178, Listing Office: Summer Place Realty

view of swimming pool featuring an outdoor structure and a deck

view of swimming pool featuring a wooden deck

$10,000 Closing Credit¹

$1,625,000

2 beds • 2 baths

210 Midway, Fire Island Pines NY 11782

#L3553492, Listing Office: Vinnie Petrarca Fire Island

wooden deck featuring an outdoor hangout area

wooden terrace featuring outdoor lounge area

$9,203 Closing Credit¹

$775,000

4 beds • 2 baths

63 Aeon Walk, Cherry Grove NY 11782

#L3552506, Listing Office: Summer Place Realty

view of pool with a wooden deck and a grill

$10,000 Closing Credit¹

$1,575,000

3 beds • 3 baths

388 Neptune Walk, Fire Island Pines NY 11782

#L3551183, Listing Office: Vinnie Petrarca Fire Island

drone / aerial view featuring a water view

birds eye view of property featuring a water view

$3,395,000

5 beds • 4.5 baths

18 Seneca St, Ocean Bay Park NY 11770

#L3539644, Listing Office: Netter Real Estate Inc

$10,000 Closing Credit¹

$949,000

1 bed • 1 bath

65 Island Walk, Lonelyville NY 11706

#L3537209, Listing Office: Cherveny Real Estate

$10,000 Closing Credit¹

$2,200,000

4 beds • 3.5 baths

44 Island Walk, Lonelyville NY 11706

#L3534720, Listing Office: Netter Real Estate Inc

$10,000 Closing Credit¹

$1,250,000

4 beds • 2 baths

917 E End Walk, Atlantique NY 11706

#L3346223, Listing Office: Eric G Ramsay Jr Assoc LLC

Fire Island, NY Real Estate Market Overview

Find your perfect home in Fire Island, NY on RocketHomes.com. Browse homes and listings in Fire Island, NY and connect with a Rocket Homes agent to get your dream home. The inventory of homes for sale in Fire Island, NY between December 2024 and January 2025 increased by 9.1%. In January 2025 median list price was $995,000 and the average listing age was 173 days. While more than 0 listings in Fire Island, NY in January 2025 were sold above asking price, there were more than 1 listings sold at asking price, and more than 4 were sold below.

From Rocket Homes Real Estate and based on county public records data

Schools near Fire Island, NY

Elementary Schools

Commack Road Elementary School
300 Commack Rd
Public District 2-5
Ruth C Kinney Elementary School
1 Spur Dr S
Public District 3-5
Sylvan Avenue Elementary School
600 Sylvan Ave
Public District KG-5

Middle Schools

Sayville Middle School
291 Johnson Ave
Public District 6-8
South Ocean Middle School
225 S Ocean Ave
Public District 6-8
East Islip Middle School
100 Redmen St
Public District 6-8

High Schools

West Islip Senior High School
1 Lions Path
Public District 9-12
Bay Shore Senior High School
155 3rd Ave
Public District 9-12
Islip High School
2508 Union Blvd
Public District 9-12

Data provided by Great Schools

Homes for sale in Fire Island, NY

Fire Island, NY Real Estate Market Overview

What is it like to live in Fire Island, NY

Overview

Housing types

Advantages

Convenience

Transportation

Schools near Fire Island, NY

Housing market reports in Suffolk County

Homes for sale near Fire Island, NY

Top real estate cities in New York