4 bedroom homes for sale in Cattaraugus County, NY

american foursquare style home with covered porch, roof with shingles, and fence

exterior space featuring a yard, a porch, and fence

4 hours on Rocket

$1,544 Closing Credit¹

$130,000

4 beds • 2 baths • 1,678 sqft

323 N 12th, Olean-City NY 14760

#R1593280, Rebecca Laborde, Listing Office: Premier Listings Real Estate

spare room with ceiling fan, dark wood-type flooring, and baseboards

empty room with arched walkways, ceiling fan, baseboards, and wood finished floors

1 day on Rocket

$1,538 Closing Credit¹

$129,500

4 beds • 2 baths • 1,072 sqft

712 Garden Ave, Olean-City NY 14760

#B1592677, Karen E Callahan, Listing Office: RE/MAX On Point

Save big

You could save thousands when you partner with Rocket Homes℠ and Rocket Mortgage®

view of front of property featuring metal roof and a front lawn

4 days on Rocket

$3,194 Closing Credit¹

$269,000

4 beds • 1 bath • 1,936 sqft

1661 Carpenter Hill Rd, Ischua NY 14743

#B1592243, Ruth Ann Gardner, Listing Office: WNY Metro Roberts Realty

kitchen featuring brown cabinets, dishwasher, a sink, and open shelves

living room featuring a ceiling fan, a fireplace, and wooden walls

7 days on Rocket

$796 Closing Credit¹

$67,000

4 beds • 1 bath • 1,562 sqft

7039 Plato Rd, East Otto NY 14729

#B1591960, Michael S Wilson, Listing Office: Michael Wilson Realty LLC

view of front of property featuring board and batten siding

living room with beamed ceiling, stairs, and wood finished floors

$6,530 Closing Credit¹

$549,900

4 beds • 2 baths • 1,752 sqft

37 Holimont Dr, Ellicottville NY 14731

#B1591833, Cathleen L Pritchard, Listing Office: ERA Team VP Real Estate

view of front of house with covered porch

italianate-style house with covered porch

$2,126 Closing Credit¹

$179,000

4 beds • 2 baths • 1,716 sqft

214 E State St, Olean-City NY 14760

#R1587180, Claudia Attard-Keary, Listing Office: Premier Listings Real Estate

view of front facade featuring covered porch

view of snowy exterior featuring a porch

$1,424 Closing Credit¹

$119,900

4 beds • 1.5 baths • 3,069 sqft

702 W Sullivan St, Olean-City NY 14760

#R1588248, Kamille J Connelly, Listing Office: Premier Listings Real Estate

Room to negotiate?

Median Sold Price

$159.1K

Avg. Sale Time

59 Days

Based on our February 2025 Market Report.

snow covered back of property featuring board and batten siding, stone siding, a balcony, and a wooden deck

living room featuring wooden ceiling, light wood finished floors, vaulted ceiling with skylight, and a fireplace

living room with vaulted ceiling with beams, wooden ceiling, a wealth of natural light, and light wood-style floors

3D tour

$10,000 Closing Credit¹

$1,650,000

4 beds • 3 baths • 2,500 sqft

25 Holimont Dr, Ellicottville NY 14731

#B1588780, Cathleen L Pritchard, Listing Office: ERA Team VP Real Estate

1514 Portville Obi Rd, Genesee NY, 14770 land for sale

Listing photo 2 for 1514 Portville Obi Rd, Genesee NY 14770

Listing photo 3 for 1514 Portville Obi Rd, Genesee NY 14770

$145,500

Land • 72.80 Acres

1514 Portville Obi Rd, Genesee NY 14770

#R1588608, Shane Vogel, Listing Office: Timberland Realty

back of house with covered porch and a yard

interior space featuring visible vents and vaulted ceiling

additional living space featuring carpet floors, wooden walls, baseboards, and vaulted ceiling

$1,069 Closing Credit¹

$90,000

4 beds • 2 baths • 3,024 sqft

37 Elm St, Franklinville NY 14737

#B1587654, Joseph M Farrauto, Listing Office: HUNT Real Estate Corporation

ranch-style home with driveway, a front lawn, and a garage

single story home featuring a front lawn, covered porch, and a shingled roof

view of side of home featuring a storage unit, a lawn, and an outdoor structure

$3,266 Closing Credit¹

$275,000

4 beds • 2.5 baths • 2,576 sqft

915 Prospect Ave, Olean-City NY 14760

#R1585482, Thomas G Fenner, Listing Office: Real Estate Pros & More

view of front of property featuring a front yard

$1,661 Closing Credit¹

$139,900

4 beds • 2 baths • 2,180 sqft

3265 Rte 394, Cold Spring NY 14772

#R1586071, Michelle Hawkins, Listing Office: Premier Listings Real Estate LLC

Backup offers

$5,213 Closing Credit¹

$439,000

4 beds • 2.5 baths • 2,208 sqft

5004 Brown Rd, Great Valley NY 14741

#B1584850, Gregory J Spako, Listing Office: ERA Team VP Real Estate

living room with light wood-type flooring

$4,976 Closing Credit¹

$419,000

4 beds • 2 baths • 1,284 sqft

6064 Rte 242 E, Ellicottville NY 14731

#R1584483, Nicholas Winiarski, Listing Office: Howard Hanna Professionals

view of front facade featuring metal roof and a wooden deck

view of front of house with metal roof and a deck

view of front of house with driveway, a view of trees, and a deck

$7,124 Closing Credit¹

$599,900

4 beds • 2.5 baths • 2,472 sqft

5393 Bryant Hill Rd, Ellicottville NY 14731

#B1581130, Joel D HusVar, Listing Office: eXp Realty

$6,395 Closing Credit¹

$538,500

4 beds • 2 baths • 1,440 sqft

71 Woods Rd, Ellicottville NY 14731

#B1580353, Caitlin H Croft, Listing Office: Iconic Real Estate

view of front of house featuring a porch and a front lawn

$3,443 Closing Credit¹

$289,900

4 beds • 2 baths • 2,356 sqft

5149 Baker Rd, Little Valley NY 14779

#B1578471, Donna M Roll, Listing Office: Howard Hanna WNY Inc.

view of front of house featuring a front lawn

view of front of property with a front yard

$1,122 Closing Credit¹

$94,500

4 beds • 2 baths • 2,025 sqft

25 Empire St, Franklinville NY 14737

#B1576016, Amanda Reynolds, Listing Office: Howard Hanna WNY Inc.

aerial view featuring a water and mountain view

Video tour

$4,689 Closing Credit¹

$394,900

4 beds • 2 baths • 2,976 sqft

1902 E River Rd, Olean-Town NY 14760

#S1574930, Travis Thurston, Listing Office: Landquest Inc.

view of front of house with a storage shed and a front yard

Backup offers

$1,465 Closing Credit¹

$123,400

4 beds • 2.5 baths • 2,292 sqft

12520 Rte 62, Conowingo NY 14726

#R1570231, Tonya Studley, Listing Office: ERA Team VP Real Estate

$4,452 Closing Credit¹

$374,900

4 beds • 5.5 baths • 5,500 sqft

1783 David Dr, Olean-Town NY 14760

#R1565825, Todd Lowe, Listing Office: Howard Hanna Professionals

traditional style home featuring driveway, a detached garage, an outbuilding, covered porch, and a front yard

unfurnished living room featuring ornamental molding, a fireplace, wood finished floors, and visible vents

kitchen featuring light tile patterned floors, ceiling fan, visible vents, and freestanding refrigerator

$1,127 Closing Credit¹

$94,900

4 beds • 1 bath • 1,538 sqft

205 N 14th St, Olean-City NY 14760

#R1568256, Paul Pezzimenti, Listing Office: Howard Hanna Professionals

view of front of home featuring a garage

view of front of house with a front yard and a mountain view

$4,382 Closing Credit¹

$369,000

4 beds • 3 baths • 2,300 sqft

4740 Rte 219, Great Valley NY 14741

#B1566794, Jennifer Courtney, Listing Office: Keller Williams Realty Lancaster

dining area with light carpet and a notable chandelier

dining area featuring a notable chandelier, light colored carpet, and a baseboard radiator

$6,401 Closing Credit¹

$539,000

4 beds • 2 baths • 1,700 sqft

81 Woods Rd, Ellicottville NY 14731

#B1562547, Cathleen L Pritchard, Listing Office: ERA Team VP Real Estate

view of front of house with covered porch and roof with shingles

$949 Closing Credit¹

$79,900

4 beds • 2 baths • 2,432 sqft

123 Fulton St, Olean-City NY 14760

#R1561407, John J. Dwaileebe, Listing Office: Howard Hanna Professionals

view of side of home featuring a balcony and a porch

view of front of home featuring a storage unit, cooling unit, and an outbuilding

$949 Closing Credit¹

$79,900

4 beds • 2 baths • 1,738 sqft

Address Not Disclosed, Olean-City NY 14760

#R1561439, John J. Dwaileebe, Listing Office: Howard Hanna Professionals

rear view of property featuring a yard, a storage unit, and a deck

$5,639 Closing Credit¹

$474,900

4 beds • 2 baths • 2,714 sqft

9200 Round Top Rd, Villenova NY 14062

#R1561138, Eric Anderson, Listing Office: Premier Listings Real Estate LLC

$6,056 Closing Credit¹

$510,000

4 beds • 2.5 baths • 1,740 sqft

3 Stone Rdg, Ellicottville NY 14731

#B1551871, Cathleen L Pritchard, Listing Office: ERA Team VP Real Estate

view of front of property with covered porch and a front yard

victorian home featuring a porch, a front yard, and brick siding

view of side of home featuring driveway, roof with shingles, a yard, and a chimney

$1,888 Closing Credit¹

$159,000

4 beds • 4 baths • 3,800 sqft

602 W Sullivan St, Olean-City NY 14760

#B1548849, Lisa C Darling, Listing Office: Homestar Realty

dining area featuring wood-type flooring and plenty of natural light

$1,780 Closing Credit¹

$149,900

4 beds • 2 baths • 2,158 sqft

604 Irving St, Olean-City NY 14760

#R1535886, Kelly Patrone, Listing Office: Howard Hanna Professionals

Cattaraugus County, NY Real Estate Market Overview

Find your perfect 4 bedroom home in Cattaraugus County, NY. Browse 4 in Cattaraugus County, NY and connect with a Rocket Homes agent to get your dream home. The number of listings in Cattaraugus County, NY decreased by 7.5% between January 2025 and February 2025. The median list price of listings available in February 2025 was $159,180, while the average time on the real estate market was 59 days. In February 2025 more than 12 listings in Cattaraugus County, NY were sold above the asking price. During the same period more than 8 listings were sold at asking price, while more than 31 were sold below.

From Rocket Homes Real Estate and based on county public records data

Schools near Cattaraugus County, NY

Elementary Schools

Washington West Elementary School
1626 Washington St
Public District PK-3
G N Chapman Elementary School
22 Main St
Public District PK-6
Portville Elementary School
500 Elm St
Public District PK-6

Middle Schools

Olean Intermediate-Middle School
401 Wayne St
Public District 4-7
Cattaraugus-Little Valley Middle School
25 N Franklin St Ste 1
Public District 5-8
Pioneer Middle School
12132 Old Olean Rd
Public District 5-8

High Schools

Hinsdale Central School
3701 Main St
Public District PK-12
Franklinville Junior-Senior High School
31 N Main St
Public District 6-12
Olean Senior High School
410 W Sullivan St
Public District 8-12

Data provided by Great Schools

4 bedroom homes for sale in Cattaraugus County, NY

Cattaraugus County, NY Real Estate Market Overview

What is it like to live in Cattaraugus County, NY

Overview

Schools near Cattaraugus County, NY

Housing market reports in Cattaraugus County

Homes for sale near Cattaraugus County, NY

Top real estate cities in New York