Single family homes for sale in Cattaraugus County, NY

6 hours on Rocket

$2,374 Closing Credit¹

$199,900

4 beds • 1 bath • 1,288 sqft

18 Bader Ave, Collins, NY 14070

#B1616524, Anna Galati, Listing office: Buffalo Home Realty

9 hours on Rocket

$1,780 Closing Credit¹

$149,900

3 beds • 1.5 baths • 1,552 sqft

126 N 8th St, Olean-City, NY 14760

#B1616244, James J Pierce, Listing office: Keller Williams Realty Lancaster

Save big

You could save thousands when you partner with Rocket Homes℠ and Rocket Mortgage®

13 hours on Rocket

$949 Closing Credit¹

$79,900

1 bed • 1 bath • 1,099 sqft

417 4th Ave, Olean-City, NY 14760

#R1615951, Michelle Fitzpatrick-Baer, Listing office: Howard Hanna Professionals - Olean

15 hours on Rocket

$1,602 Closing Credit¹

$134,900

3 beds • 2 baths • 1,697 sqft

12 Brooklyn St, Portville, NY 14770

#B1616008, Janna Davis, Listing office: ERA Team VP Real Estate

1 day on Rocket

$236 Closing Credit¹

$19,900

3 beds • 1 bath • 1,406 sqft

124 W Green St, Olean-City, NY 14760

#R1616292, Edgardo Molfino, Listing office: Real Estate Advantage

1 day on Rocket

$7,421 Closing Credit¹

$624,900

4 beds • 1.5 baths • 864 sqft

328 Lakeview Blvd, Machias, NY 14042

#B1615949, Kacie Schrader, Listing office: Howard Hanna WNY Inc.

1 day on Rocket

$1,958 Closing Credit¹

$164,900

3 beds • 1.5 baths • 1,248 sqft

568 York St, Olean-City, NY 14760

#R1613323, Daniel Terhune, Listing office: Century 21 Turner Brokers

Room to negotiate?

Median Sold Price

$161.5K

Avg. Sale Time

76 Days

Based on our May 2025 Market Report.

1 day on Rocket

$2,363 Closing Credit¹

$199,000

4 beds • 2 baths • 1,660 sqft

4 Cobb Ave, Yorkshire, NY 14042

#B1615900, Joshua James, Listing office: Keller Williams Realty WNY

2 days on Rocket

$830 Closing Credit¹

$69,900

1 bed • 1 bath • 384 sqft

415 Court St Unit A, Little Valley, NY 14755

#R1615875, Richard McMahon, Listing office: Real Estate Advantage

2 days on Rocket

$2,077 Closing Credit¹

$174,900

4 beds • 2 baths • 1,300 sqft

5046 Whig St, Little Valley, NY 14779

#B1615296, David A Blanchard, Listing office: Keller Williams Realty Lancaster

2 days on Rocket

$1,478 Closing Credit¹

$124,500

2 beds • 1 bath • 1,112 sqft

151 Chipmonk Rd, Allegany, NY 14753

#R1615218, Kelly Patrone, Listing office: Howard Hanna Professionals

3 days on RocketTour

$10,000 Closing Credit¹

$995,000

3 beds • 3 baths • 2,212 sqft

5250 Brown Rd, Great Valley, NY 14741

#R1615386, Paul Pezzimenti, Listing office: Howard Hanna Professionals - Olean

3 days on Rocket

$6,828 Closing Credit¹

$575,000

4 beds • 2.5 baths • 2,472 sqft

5393 Bryant Hill Rd, Ellicottville, NY 14731

#B1615581, Joel D HusVar, Listing office: eXp Realty

3 days on Rocket

$3,741 Closing Credit¹

$315,000

3 beds • 1.5 baths • 734 sqft

329 Lakeview Blvd, Machias, NY 14042

#B1614235, Kacie Schrader, Listing office: Howard Hanna WNY Inc.

3 days on Rocket

$1,484 Closing Credit¹

$125,000

4 beds • 2 baths • 1,264 sqft

67 Harriet St, Allegany, NY 14706

#R1614396, Paul Pezzimenti, Listing office: Howard Hanna Professionals - Olean

5 days on Rocket

$6,649 Closing Credit¹

$559,900

3 beds • 3 baths • 2,840 sqft

2328 Gowanda Zoar Rd, Collins, NY 14070

#B1614022, Kathleen E Komenda, Listing office: Howard Hanna WNY Inc.

6 days on Rocket

$1,661 Closing Credit¹

$139,900

4 beds • 1.5 baths • 2,117 sqft

417 E State St, Salamanca-City, NY 14779

#B1614589, Ciji L VanDyke, Listing office: RE/MAX On Point

6 days on Rocket

$1,424 Closing Credit¹

$119,900

2 beds • 1 bath • 797 sqft

421 E Connell St, Olean-City, NY 14760

#R1614388, Paul Pezzimenti, Listing office: Howard Hanna Professionals

6 days on Rocket

$2,611 Closing Credit¹

$219,900

3 beds • 1.5 baths • 1,628 sqft

1550 Portville Obi Rd, Genesee, NY 14770

#R1614389, Paul Pezzimenti, Listing office: Howard Hanna Professionals - Olean

6 days on Rocket

$5,047 Closing Credit¹

$425,000

3 beds • 3 baths • 1,805 sqft

21 Messinger Rd, Randolph, NY 14772

#R1613816, Sandra Calalesina, Listing office: Century 21 Turner Brokers

7 days on RocketTour

$2,968 Closing Credit¹

$249,900

4 beds • 2 baths • 2,976 sqft

1902 E River Rd, Olean-Town, NY 14760

#S1614676, Travis Thurston, Listing office: Landquest Inc.

7 days on Rocket

$771 Closing Credit¹

$64,900

1 bed • 1 bath • 1,280 sqft

5336 Riley Rd, Ashford, NY 14171

#R1613509, Cindy M Bramer, Listing office: Metro Kirsch Real Estate, Inc.

$1,841 Closing Credit¹

$155,000

2 beds • 1.5 baths • 1,234 sqft

918 Crown St, Olean-City, NY 14760

#R1614353, Paul Pezzimenti, Listing office: Howard Hanna Professionals

$1,176 Closing Credit¹

$99,000

0.5 bath • 3,861 sqft

13 Church St, Yorkshire, NY 14042

#R1614133, Andrea Eckman, Listing office: Century 21 Turner Brokers

$1,900 Closing Credit¹

$160,000

3 beds • 2 baths • 1,856 sqft

7491 S Grove Rd, Lyndon, NY 14737

#B1613980, Susan A Nagel, Listing office: Howard Hanna WNY Inc.

$2,078 Closing Credit¹

$175,000

3 beds • 1 bath • 1,020 sqft

5757 Rte 98, Great Valley, NY 14741

#R1613572, Sandra J Goode, Listing office: Howard Hanna Professionals

$2,968 Closing Credit¹

$249,900

1 bed • 1 bath • 800 sqft

3883 Block Rd, Yorkshire, NY 14042

#B1613349, Aimee B Cooper, Listing office: Own NY Real Estate LLC

51 Wilson St, Salamanca-City, NY 14779 - view of front of house with a front lawn

$534 Closing Credit¹

$45,000

2 beds • 1 bath • 1,215 sqft

51 Wilson St, Salamanca-City, NY 14779

#B1612946, Colby Garza, Listing office: HUNT Real Estate Corporation

Backup offers

$1,543 Closing Credit¹

$129,900

4 beds • 2 baths • 2,156 sqft

136 N 10th St, Olean-City, NY 14760

#R1613265, Cynthia Sellstrom, Listing office: ERA Team VP Real Estate

$2,969 Closing Credit¹

$250,000

3 beds • 2 baths • 1,624 sqft

2320 Sheldon Dr, Allegany, NY 14706

#B1613279, Karen E Callahan, Listing office: RE/MAX On Point

$1,661 Closing Credit¹

$139,900

3 beds • 1.5 baths • 1,019 sqft

136 S 12th St, Olean-City, NY 14760

#R1612781, Claudia Attard-Keary, Listing office: Premier Listings Real Estate

$4,809 Closing Credit¹

$405,000

4 beds • 3.5 baths • 3,099 sqft

158 Hawthorn Ln, Allegany, NY 14706

#R1613058, Regis Handley, Listing office: Howard Hanna Professionals - Olean

Tour

$5,343 Closing Credit¹

$449,900

3 beds • 1.5 baths • 2,200 sqft

9854 Rte 240, Ashford, NY 14171

#B1612764, Melanie A Pritchard, Listing office: ERA Team VP Real Estate

Tour

$4,689 Closing Credit¹

$394,900

4 beds • 2 baths • 2,976 sqft

1902 E River Rd, Olean-Town, NY 14760

#S1612895, Travis Thurston, Listing office: Landquest Inc.

$1,602 Closing Credit¹

$134,900

3 beds • 1.5 baths • 1,816 sqft

207 N Clinton St, Olean-City, NY 14760

#R1611335, Christine Calbi, Listing office: Premier Listings Real Estate

$1,958 Closing Credit¹

$164,900

3 beds • 2 baths • 1,320 sqft

130 S 6th St, Olean-City, NY 14760

#B1612379, Thomas P Butler, Listing office: Southern Tier Realty Co. Inc.

Backup offers

$2,494 Closing Credit¹

$210,000

5 beds • 3 baths • 2,550 sqft

104 6th St, Little Valley, NY 14755

#R1612702, Melissa Bedell, Listing office: ERA Team VP-Arcade

$3,859 Closing Credit¹

$325,000

4 beds • 2 baths • 2,040 sqft

9983 Deer Creek Rd, Genesee, NY 14770

#R1612713, Claudia Attard-Keary, Listing office: Premier Listings Real Estate

$593 Closing Credit¹

$49,900

3 beds • 2 baths • 1,384 sqft

1182 Promised Land Rd, Portville, NY 14760

#R1611347, Claudia Attard-Keary, Listing office: Premier Listings Real Estate

$3,444 Closing Credit¹

$290,000

4 beds • 2 baths • 2,172 sqft

4712 Raecher Rd, Great Valley, NY 14741

#R1611144, Sandra J Goode, Listing office: Howard Hanna Professionals

Cattaraugus County, NY Real Estate Market Overview

There are 141 single family homes for sale in Cattaraugus County, NY. The following market insights reflect all property types in the Cattaraugus County, NY real estate market. The number of homes for sale in Cattaraugus County, NY decreased by 2.7% between April 2025 and May 2025. In May 2025, listings were on the market for 76 days. During the same period, the median list price in this real estate market was $161,586. In May 2025, from all listings sold in Cattaraugus County, NY there were more than 5 sold above asking price, over 24 sold below and more than 6 were sold right at the asked price.

From Rocket Homes Real Estate and based on county public records data

What is it like to live in Cattaraugus County, NY

Overview

Cattaraugus County is located in New York. There are roughly 79,669 residents, living in 31,939 households. The average temperature for Cattaraugus County this time of the year is low of 50F and high of 76F. On average, Cattaraugus County gets about 4.93 inches of precipitation in June. Most residents are home owners (72%), have a high school diploma (50%) and are single, no kids (42%).

Data provided by Home Junction

Schools near Cattaraugus County, NY

Elementary Schools

Washington West Elementary School
1626 Washington St
Public District PK-3
G N Chapman Elementary School
22 Main St
Public District PK-6
Portville Elementary School
500 Elm St
Public District PK-6

Middle Schools

Olean Intermediate-Middle School
401 Wayne St
Public District 4-7
Cattaraugus-Little Valley Middle School
25 N Franklin St Ste 1
Public District 5-8
Pioneer Middle School
12132 Old Olean Rd
Public District 5-8

High Schools

Hinsdale Central School
3701 Main St
Public District PK-12
Franklinville Junior-Senior High School
31 N Main St
Public District 6-12
Olean Senior High School
410 W Sullivan St
Public District 8-12

Data provided by Great Schools

Single family homes for sale in Cattaraugus County, NY

Cattaraugus County, NY Real Estate Market Overview

What is it like to live in Cattaraugus County, NY

Overview

Explore popular home types in Cattaraugus County, NY

Related homes in Cattaraugus County, NY

Schools near Cattaraugus County, NY

Housing market reports in Cattaraugus County

Homes for sale near Cattaraugus County, NY

Top real estate cities in New York